Carlyle Grass Fed Whey Protein Powder | 2lb | 33g of Protein Per Serving | Unflavored | Sugar and Hormone Free | Non-GMO and Gluten Free Supplement | By Herbage Farmstead | Sugar and Hormone Free | Unflavored | Vegetarian, Non-GMO and Gluten Free Supplement | By Herbage Farmstead

Amazon reviewers say this Carlyle grass fed whey protein is generally liked for its neutral, bland taste, solid protein content, and good value, but mixability is inconsistent and some users struggle to get it to dissolve well.

Review sites and fake-review analysis pages echo that pattern: the product is usually described as clean-tasting, easy to use in shakes or recipes, and affordable for grass-fed whey, while texture and blending are the main complaints.

Trustpilot coverage of Carlyle as a brand is limited but suggests the company’s products are generally well received, and one third-party article also highlights this powder as a budget-friendly clean protein option.

• Amazon reviewers: positive on taste, protein amount, and price; mixed on mixability.
• Fakespot: broadly positive sentiment, with recurring notes about neutral taste and value.
• ReviewMeta: Carlyle brand listings show many reviews, but adjusted counts suggest caution about review quality.
• YouTube results include at least one video that appears to be an Amazon product review for this exact Carlyle powder, plus a broader whey-protein video that mentions Carlyle in discussion.